PDA

View Full Version : How to filter Ideas posted by members in Brainstorm section.


dtpy
02-06-2008, 08:28 PM
Here's the deal. A lot of ideas are posted here.

Most of them are bad.
A lot of them are useless.
But some are really good.

I understand that even though Justin is very active on forum, he still can not read them all and and their replies.

So: Why not just assign some people that are active in forum and can judge these ideas effectively. These people will analyze them, decide if they are good for both Rampid's and players' interests.

After they have filtered the ideas, they just forward them to admins for further inspection and possible implementation.

I suggest assigning people that have proven they can judge effectively and have some kind of logic to what they are trying to say. :)
You should pick someone from every crew and there should about 5 of them. If the idea gets at least 3 out 5 votes, it gets forwarded and recommended to admins.

My suggestions would be: Wizzy, Sparda, champ, me and one more that I can not come up with right now.

I did not pick Hec, even though he comes up with a lot of ideas, cause he just seems stupid to me.
I didn't pick snake either, cause he seems almost the same as Hec to me, but that's only from what I have seen in forums. I have never talked to him. Champ seems like the better option, and there are not any other Ch members active in forums.

Justin, or someone who can decide if this should go through or not, please post :)
ty.

PS: To the nub forum mod (Swudeson) that warned me: Saying that Sky is gay is not an insult, because he really IS. Are you homophobic ? Do you consider that being gay is a disgrace and calling someone "gay" should be considered an insult?

Edit: If u insist on picking someone from OI for idea filtering, I suggest Taz, but he's not really active in forums, and I don't really know Maka and Pimpa.

Sparda1234
02-06-2008, 08:52 PM
Pretty good idea, i wouldnt mind it really, say 1 person gets the all the posts saved into a txt and then every few days have a chat with those people who are picked to sort through them and then post one by one and vote then they get forwarded like you said.

Egnar
02-06-2008, 08:55 PM
I'm hurt in saying that i'm not objective :( - Also. . A lot of forums moderate the suggestion forums so moderators need to choose which threads make it (based on merit). I like that idea.

Rampid_Misery
02-06-2008, 09:41 PM
All the brainstorming threads get looked at already.

dtowns
02-06-2008, 09:41 PM
All the brainstorming threads get looked at already.
Doesn't seem like it ....

champ
02-07-2008, 06:14 AM
On the old forums the Forum moderator stickied 1 thread with hotlinks to all the good ideas. We could do this again if a number of regular posters said "hey, this idea is really good, good enough for the hotlink thread!"

PlayaFoSho
02-07-2008, 06:54 AM
You couldnt come up with my name?

Egnar
02-07-2008, 10:52 AM
On the old forums the Forum moderator stickied 1 thread with hotlinks to all the good ideas. We could do this again if a number of regular posters said "hey, this idea is really good, good enough for the hotlink thread!"
That was me!