pic evaulation

[Itai]

Alright, ive had a lot of very talented artists create profile pictures for me, from the same render. I have bought all the pictures that have been made, so i don't want anybody to feel bad about this thread...

I have chosen out the best of the best pictures, but now i got the luxurious problem - i cant seem to decide which one is the best. So i would like you guys to help me. Which picture out of these 4 is the best?

a)http://i55.photobucket.com/albums/g130/TorItai/baccala/outwarplayer8jn6.jpg b)http://i55.photobucket.com/albums/g130/TorItai/baccala/ce7620e4.jpg

c)http://i55.photobucket.com/albums/g130/TorItai/baccala/b4yyjr.gif d)http://i55.photobucket.com/albums/g130/TorItai/baccala/CorleoneV2.jpg

[PlayaFoSho]

Alright, ive had a lot of very talented artists create profile pictures for me, from the same render. I have bought all the pictures that have been made, so i don't want anybody to feel bad about this thread...

I have chosen out the best of the best pictures, but now i got the luxurious problem - i cant seem to decide which one is the best. So i would like you guys to help me. Which picture out of these 4 is the best?

a)http://i55.photobucket.com/albums/g130/TorItai/baccala/outwarplayer8jn6.jpg b)http://i55.photobucket.com/albums/g130/TorItai/baccala/ce7620e4.jpg

c)http://i55.photobucket.com/albums/g130/TorItai/baccala/b4yyjr.gif d)http://i55.photobucket.com/albums/g130/TorItai/baccala/CorleoneV2.jpg


I like the render layout in B but hate the background. I like the background and effects in A but hate the render placement.

So id have others try some more pics lol

[UndaLife]

a) Way too messy, incorrect lightsource.
b) Lovely text, background's slightly too retarded
c) Eww, everything about it = beginner
d) The render is too contrasted, looks messy

Personally I'd go for b) as it is easily the best pic maker there, has more fx and overall looks more professional.

[Gangsta1337]

I have bought all the pictures that have been made, so i don't want anybody to feel bad about this thread...




didnt pay for mine

[NightThaProphet]

I would say Mussy's, very nice text and render placement, background may be a bit blah, but its best outta those.

[SkatrBill]

a) Way too messy, incorrect lightsource.
b) Lovely text, background's slightly too retarded
c) Eww, everything about it = beginner
d) The render is too contrasted, looks messy

Personally I'd go for b) as it is easily the best pic maker there, has more fx and overall looks more professional.

i agree with everything cept w/e pic you would go for... i don't know what pic. i wouldn't say B cause it looks like the dudes gonna puke

[Itai]

background may be a bit blah
Hey Skip! you want to try to make one thats better? show me your skills... ill pay for it :)

didnt pay for mine
ey, do you feel bad about this thread mate? just tell me...

[chgangstapur1]

ey, do you feel bad about this thread mate? just tell me...

of course i do

[Itai]

of course i do

so, i guess you want to be payed for the pic you made for me now... whats your ow name?

[J.Christ]

i dont like any of them, maybe its just a hard render to work with, but if any pick b

[mrxafiar]

Pic B seems like the best one in my opinion, C is begginer all over it, D is regular, A is good.